Opinions surrounding the implications and concerns about government proposals for our NHS from the current Conservative/Lib Dem government swing from support to abhorrence.
We are looking at a real culture shift from socialised and public health care to one partially removed from government control that allows for more privatised elements (this means that more private companies will be able to provide parts of NHS services, rather than the amount allowed now.)
They also propose to change the way the NHS is administrated. Instead of today’s PCT’s, they propose we move to clinical commissioning groups (CCGs).
For some reason, CCGs are going to be allowed to choose where their patients come from. Instead of geographical allocation (for example, Gloucestershire’s PCT administrates health care for Gloucestershire), CCGs will be able to build a patient list out of people who are potentially geographically separate. They also will choose who provides which services to their area’s public health care providers.
These changes have sparked two concerns.
First, Professor Allyson Pollock of Queen Mary, University of London, thinks that changing the way patient lists are made will make it harder to tell who’s being helped and what help they need.
She is worried that the change in patient list organisation is badly-defined and going to harm data collection and understanding.
She also predicts that it will be harder to ensure proper coverage and fair provision and that figures for long-term bed management and resource provision will also be impeded.
Secondly, a TUC-funded research group has noted that nearly half of the CCG groups they studied have many doctors that could make more money if their companies are chosen to provide health care services for the CCGs that they work for. Currently, 22 out of the 50 studied had substantial external financial interests in private health-care provision.
This sparks concerns that NHS provision may start to be affected by personal interest for making money, rather than what’s best for the patients and the NHS itself.
What do you think? Do you worry these things will change your NHS for the worse? Maybe you think it’s only natural that doctors would work with other health companies and this isn’t an issue? If you want to read more and have a subscription, you can access the studies at www.bmj.com
